7 Best Similac Alternative Formulas: Choose the Perfect Nutritive Formula To Help The Growth Of Your Newborn

Share this
To help parents nourish their child, infant, and baby formulas have been used as an alternative to or supplement along with breast milk for a long period of time. And there is hardly anyone who hasn’t heard of the brand Similac when it comes to choosing a formula for their kid. The brand undoubtedly offers healthy nutrition and has been recommended by many parents out there!
But it’s also true that your baby might be reluctant to the Similac alternative, simply either because they don’t like it, or they might be allergic to it! So, how will you know what’s best for your child when there are so many substitute options out there?
For you, some of the best Similac alternative formulas from known or perhaps not-so-known brands, like Enfamil, Gerber, Burt’s Bees, etc., have been gathered. They are all affordable, and each one is filled with essential nutrients and vitamins that your baby needs.
Let’s take a look!
Best Similac Alternatives for Newborn Baby
Choose the best formula based on the preference and adaptability of your child from the above-listed best Similac alternative formulas.
Enfamil Gentlease Baby Formula to Support Brain Development
- 🍼ALL-IN-ONE COMFORT FOR YOUR LITTLE ONE: Enfamil NeuroPro Gentlease is thoughtfully crafted to provide all-in-one comfort, designed to ease fussiness, crying, gas, and spit-up within just 24-hours, so you and your baby can enjoy precious moments of peace
- 🧠 NURTURING BRAIN DEVELOPMENT: Our formula has expert-recommended DHA, known to support your baby's growing brain, supporting their milestones with confidence
- 💧 HuMO6 GENTLE + IMMUNE BLEND§: Enfamil NeuroPro Gentlease features our exclusive HuMO6 gentle + immune blend, to support your baby's immune system, because your baby's well-being is our top priority
- 🤱🏼 NUTRITION DESIGNED FOR YOUR INFANT: Designed with care for babies up to 12 months, Enfamil formula includes easy-to-digest proteins, vitamins & minerals
- 👨🏽⚕️ TRUSTED BY PARENTS & PEDIATRICIANS*: Enfamil is the #1 Trusted Infant Formula Brand by Pediatricians* & Parents and the #1 Trusted Brand for Brain-Building & Immune Support
What is your outlook on a formula made with easy-to-digest nutrients and clinically proven to relieve your baby from the stress of gas, spit-up, crying, or fussiness within 24 hours? The first one on the list is Gentlease baby formula from one of the biggest brand names advised by pediatricians, Enfamil!
Specifications
- The formula is a milk-based powder filled with iron and nutrients like DHA and choline
- 4 cans of this infant formula make up the package
- You will find the weight of each can to be close to 27.7 ounces
- You will get the SNAP (Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program) benefit while purchasing it
- Recommended for babies ages 0 to 12 months
The carbohydrate and protein content present here are partially hydrolyzed nonfat milk and protein, corn syrup, which helps reduce the fuss of indigestion and lactose intolerance for your baby. And the dual prebiotics makes them stronger.
With no added sugar or preservatives, this formula has a blend of easy-to-digest protein for babies with delicate digestive health. There are also nutrients like DHA and choline to promote eye and brain functioning. And not to mention, a blend of nutritious vitamins and minerals aids in healthy growth and development!
Lower sugar content, reduced lactose, and more natural ingredients- if these are what you want in your baby’s milk, you can switch to this one!
Pros
- An easy-to-digest protein combination for your child’s sensitive tummy
- Choline and DHA work together to support brain development
- Has been clinically proven to lessen fussiness, gas, or crying of your baby
- Specially formulated to suit the nutritional need of even a newborn
- Does not contain any gluten
Cons
- Some consumers complain that their cans arrived dented
- It has got a slightly strong smell
Gerber Good Start GentlePro Formula Powder (GentlePro Probiotics)
- Soothing Nutrition: Modeled after the complete nutrition and gentleness of breastmilk, this formula offers nutrition for babies up to 12 months experiencing colic, excessive crying, fussiness and gas
- Probiotic Formula: Good Start Soothe formula features prebiotics, Comfort Proteins and probiotics that improve the good bacteria in tummies and promote soft stools; It's our closest formula to breastmilk
- Give Your Baby a Good Start: Your baby’s nutritional needs evolve over time. That's why we created the Gerber Good Start line. Made to comfort your baby's tummy and available in a range of products
- Wholesome Options: Introduce your infant to complimentary staged products like single grain Cereals and 1st Foods fruit and veggie purees with Gerber infant formulas, probiotic supplements and more
- Nutrition For Growing: Like your baby, we're always growing and learning. More than ever we're committed to being your partner in parenthood with quality ingredients, nutritious food and expert guidance
Next up is the Similac pro-advanced alternative formula from Gerber Good Start, the GentlePro advanced complete nutrition. To make this one, the developers have chosen 2′-FL HMO and probiotics that boost healthy bacteria in your baby’s gut and are similar to those present in breast milk!
Specification:
- You will get 6 packs of the powdered item, each worth 20 ounce
- It can be fed to babies ages up to 12 months
- Per 100 calories, 2.2-grams protein content is present
- This is one of the few formulas that contains HMO (human milk oligosaccharides)
- Contains milk, soy, prebiotics, ARA, DHA, etc.
This formula, which is patterned after the complete nourishment and softness of breastmilk, offers perfect nutrition for babies up until the age of 12 months. The gentle recipe includes prebiotics, DHA, and comfort proteins, which are little proteins that are simple to digest for your child’s tiny tummies. And No added preservatives, sugars, or growth hormones is another plus point!
Enzymatically hydrolyzed and reduced in mineral whey protein concentrate makes up the formula, which reduces the discomfort while digesting. Your baby’s brain and eye development are also ensured by the formula, alongside strong immunity.
You can use this as a Similac-sensitive alternative if your baby requires a milder and easier-to-digest drink.
Pros
- Made focusing on breastmilk’s complete nutrients and tenderness.
- It has 2′-FL HMO, a probiotic similar to the ones found in breast milk
- DHA supports healthy eye and brain development
- To keep the health of the gut, there is the probiotic B.lactis
- Contains small proteins that are mild on your baby’s delicate tummy
Cons
- Doesn’t have an essential breast milk component MFGM(milk fat globule membrane)
- Contains vegetable oil which some kids might be sensitive too
Gerber Good Start SoothePro Baby Formula Powder
- Gentle Nutrition: Modeled after the complete nutrition and gentleness of breastmilk, this formula offers complete nutrition for babies up to 12 months
- Probiotic Formula: Our Gentle formula is specially designed with easy to digest Comfort Proteins, prebiotics (important components in breastmilk), and DHA to help support brain and eye development
- Give Your Baby a Good Start: Your baby’s nutritional needs evolve over time. That's why we created the Gerber Good Start line. Made to comfort your baby's tummy and available in a range of products
- Wholesome Options: Introduce your infant to complimentary staged products like single grain Cereals and 1st Foods fruit and veggie purees with Gerber infant formulas, probiotic supplements and more
- Nutrition For Growing: Like your baby, we're always growing and learning. More than ever we're committed to being your partner in parenthood with quality ingredients, nutritious food and expert guidance
Crying, colic, crankiness, bloat, uncomfortable Poops, mild spit-up – these 6 problems that your baby faces are addressed in the SoothePro formula by Gerber Good Start, one of the first and only formulas with 2′-FL HMO and Probiotics!
Specifications:
- You will get a milk-based formula with iron and other essential
- Newborns to 12-month-olds can be fed with this formula
- It comes in a pack of 6 where each one weighing almost 1.2 pound
- If features probiotic L.reuteri and FL HMO(human milk oligosaccharide)
- Made with non-GMO ingredients
This formula contains comfort proteins that are easily digested by the stomach. Moreover, there is a comforting probiotic present too, L.reuteri; this one has passed the clinical test to reduce crying time by 50%. Additionally, to ease your toddler’s fussiness, the carbohydrate blend has 30 % lactose!
The soothing blend of prebiotics, probiotics, and comfort protein promotes soft tools in your baby and reduces colic and spit-ups! This non-GMO milk-based formula has no artificial ingredients or growth hormones and is totally safe!
If your baby is sensitive to lactose, you can use the Gerber SoothPro as an alternative to Similac Pro sensitive.
Pros
- Prepared with a healthy combination of comfort proteins, prebiotics, and probiotics
- It has 2′-FL HMO, a probiotic similar to the ones found in breast milk
- Contains L.reuteri which reduced crying duration by 50%, clinically proven
- Does not contain any genetically engineered ingredients
- No GMO ingredient, artificial growth hormones, or added sugar present
Cons
- Contains palm oil, which might initiate constipation in some children
- The formula scoop is a bit inconvenient
Enfamil Infant Formula (Milk Based Baby Formula with Iron)
- A Neuro Completed formula that has important nutrients, such as brain-nourishing choline and DHA
- Enfamil Infant formula is tailored to meet the nutritional needs of babies aged 0 through 12 months.
- Enfamil is the #1 infant formula brand recommended by pediatricians.
- Enfamil Infant also has a dual prebiotics blend designed to help support a baby's own natural defenses
- #1 TRUSTED BRAND: Enfamil is the #1 Trusted Brand for Brain-building & Immune Support
Omega-3 DHA and choline, 2 key brain-nourishing nutrients for your baby, as well as a blend of 2 prebiotics to boost your baby’s natural immunity, make up this beast-milk-inspired Infant formula from Enfamil! Let’s look at some of its features.
Specifications:
- The infant formula is a milk-based powder with iron
- It features 4 cans of the formula, each being 21.1 ounce
- You will find nutrients like DHA and choline in the formula
- It can meet your baby’s nutritional needs for the first 12 months
- No additional sucrose, corn, chemical growth hormones, antibiotics, or genetically modified organisms (GMOs) here
Nonfat milk, whey protein concentrate, and lactose- are some of the ingredients found in this milk-based baby formula. And you will be pleased to know that there are no additional table sugar (sucrose), chemical growth hormones, corn, antibiotics, or genetically modified organisms (GMOs) present.
This nutritional formula is designed to address the nutritional needs of infants up to the age of 12 months. Two key brain-nourishing nutrients for your baby, Choline and Omega-3 DHA, as well as a blend of two prebiotics to boost your baby’s natural immunity, is included here!
For milk with less added sugar and a gentler formula, you can go with the Enfamil Infant one!
Pros
- Your infant will get complete nutrition for the first 12 months of his or her life.
- Choline and DHA are present in the development of an infant’s brain.
- Promotes your baby’s immune system with a dual-prebiotics combination.
- To promote natural defense, there are 2 prebiotics present
- Antibiotics, gluten, and GMO-free formula
Cons
- Has a slightly strong smell
- Does not have any MFGM
Enfamil Enspire Gentlease Baby Formula
- ALL IN ONE COMFORT: Enfamil Gentlease is scientifically formulated to help ease fussiness, crying, gas and spit-up in 24 hours
- EXPERT RECOMMENDED DHA: Enfamil Gentlease has expert recommended brain building DHA
- COMPLETE NURTITION: Contains important nutrients found in breast milk to help support cognitive brain development through their first 12 months
- NON-GMO: No added table sugar (sucrose), corn, artificial growth hormones, antibiotics or GMOs
- #1 TRUSTED BRAND: Enfamil is the #1 Trusted Brand for Brain-building & Immune Support
Up next is the Enspire Gentlease formula from Enfamil. Formulated with MFGM components as well as Lactoferrin, two essential components found in breast milk, the brand claims that this is the closest formula to breast milk they’ve ever created for easing fussiness and gas!
Specifications:
- It is a milk-based powder drink filled with iron
- Contains 4 – 1.81 pound refill boxes
- You will find Lactoferrin and MFGM components here
- While purchasing, you’ll get a SNAP (Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program) benefit.
- Suitable for babies aged from 0 to 12 months
This non-GMO baby formula has been designed to provide comprehensive nourishment through their first 12 months. It is prepared with easy digestive protein chunks, and you will find the lactose content reduced to 20% for sensitive babies. Corn syrup solids, partially hydrolyzed nonfat milk, and whet protein-lipid concentrate are some of the vital ingredients.
Two important components that you will find in breast milk, Lactoferrin, and MFGM, are included in this gentle formula. This makes it one of the preferable breast milk alternative formulas designed for a baby’s crying, gas, or fussiness. Lactoferrin works on immunity, while DHA and choline work on brain-building!
This is one of the best Similac pro-sensitive alternatives if you want a sugar-free, easy-to-digest, and vitamin-filled formula!
Pros
- Reduced crying and fussiness within 24 hours
- Meets the complete nutritional need for the first year of your baby.
- The lactose content has been reduced to 20% for toddlers sensitive to milk
- Brain nourishing nutrients DHA and choline are included in the formula
- Does not have gluten or GMO ingredients
Cons
- The price of this formula is a bit high
- Has a slightly strong fragrance
Else Plant-Based Complete Nutrition Formula for Toddlers
- CERTIFIED GOODNESS: Else Nutrition Toddler Omega is certified with the following certifications – Clean Label Purity Award, Plant Based, Beyond Soy, and Low Fodmap.
- A REAL ALTERNATIVE TO COW’S MILK WITH CLEAN NUTRITION: This is a real choice besides dairy. Made with >80% minimally processed, whole food ingredients: buckwheat, almond and tapioca. Produced with the cleanest process we can use with no alteration to the ingredient’s chemical structure for a more natural digestion.
- WITH ESSENTIAL OMEGA 3 & 6, Else Toddler Omega is a complete and balanced nutritional drink designed to support your little one’s growth and development, as well as promote natural digestion, through the combination of healthy unsaturated fats, fibers, and protein.
- NUTRITIONALLY BALANCED: Else Nutrition Toddler Omega contains plant protein originating from almonds and buckwheat supplemented with additional free amino acids and a diverse fat profile derived from almond butter, coconut oil, and rapeseed oil, and sunflower oil. It is fortified with over 20 essential vitamins and minerals to support healthy growth & development.
- TRY ELSE RISK-FREE TODAY: Else's mission is to reimagine kids’ nutrition, with plant-based complete nutrition products who taste good yet with ~50% less sugar than other leading brands. Backed by a 100% Satisfaction Guarantee! (Satisfaction guarantees may be rejected by Amazon)
Prepared with 92% whole plant ingredients, there is this plant-based alternative to soy formula and cow’s milk! This organic nutritional drink from Else was developed to help your child grow in a healthy way.
Specifications:
- It is a plant-based organic formula
- Come in a pack of 4 where each one weighs 29 ounce
- You will not find any gluten or corn syrup in the powder
- There is also no soy or dairy included in the formula
- The organic ingredients are USDA certified meaning there is no genetic modification or added antibiotic, hormone, or preservatives
Dairy-free, GMO-free, soy-free, corn-syrup-free, gluten-free- if your child has lactose intolerance or dietary restrictions, this plant-based formula is the one that can help your toddler for the first 12 months. Organic almond butter, organic tapioca, and organic buckwheat these plant-based ingredients that make up the major of this vegan formula.
It is USDA-certified organic which means it has been farmed and processed in accordance with federal criteria for soil quality, animal treatment, insect management, and the use of additives. So you can rely on the safety of this formula! Plus, the fiber, minerals, and vitamins are in abundance in the formula as they come from whole food.
Overall, for babies who need special care in a dairy-free way, this formula is the one you can rely on!
Pros
- Tapioca, almond, and buckwheat constitute 92% of the formula
- Prepared with real foods in their natural form, non-GMO
- Helpful for toddlers with lactose intolerance
- Contains no highly processed ingredients or purified oil blends
- Has essential vitamins and minerals to support the growth activities
Cons
- Contains tree nuts(almonds) which your baby might be allergic to
- Has a slightly bland taste and flavor
Burt’s Bees Baby Organic Baby Formula
- NUTRITIONALLY SAFE: Bubs Supreme Infant Formula Stage 1 is an Australian-made baby formula exclusively formulated for tiny tummies ages 0-6 months, feeding up to 8 times per day, all while made to ensure safety, quality, purity, and nutrition
- PURE & BALANCED: Our Bubs Supreme is premium and naturally sourced farm fresh A2 beta-casein protein milk of the highest quality from Australia, proudly sourced from our high-quality farmers committed to care
- GOODNESS FROM THE FARM: Bubs Supreme Stage 1 Formula is securely blended, with Clean Label, non-GMO ingredients, no artificial colors, flavors, or preservatives, and selected for Clean Label Purity Award
- NO HIDDEN NASTIES: Our Bubs Supreme Infant Formula gives parents peace of mind and babies a happy start to their life with natural A2 beta-casein protein cow's milk, along with a symbiotic blend of Probiotics and Prebiotics, Lutein, and Omega 3
- TRUSTED FOR OVER 17 YEARS: Founder Kristy Carr, a mom of three, has a mission to inspire the next generation of happy babies, with Clean Label nutritional products that provide the foundation for setting up a lifetime of good eating habits
Looking for an organic formula that is comprehensively nutritive and consciously modeled after breast milk? The final one on today’s list is the Burt’s Bee baby organic formula, which has been clinically proven to ensure that your kid gets the desired nutrients for growth!
Specifications:
- It features a milk-based powder with essential vitamins and iron
- You will get 4 packs of the formula each worth 23.2 ounces
- The age limit for consumption is 0-12 months
- It contains DHA with no hexane extractions
- The formula is made with USDA-certified organics which means there are no added hormones, preservatives, antibiotics, or genetic engineering.
This ultra-gentle formula promises to give your baby complete nutrition for the first year and fulfills the FDA and USDA standards. Some of the ingredients included here are Omega 3 DHA, Omega 6 ARA, organic partially hydrolyzed whey protein, organic lactose, organic coconut oil, and organic soy oil. All these nutrients are non-GMO with no added preservatives.
Vitamins A, D, E, K, and calcium in the formula work together to make the child stronger. DHA helps in vision and brain development, and the easy-to-digest proteins help to reduce the crankiness of your kid. There is gluten, sensitive start, or artificial ingredients present here, which makes it a healthy drink.
This formula has gained a great level of acceptance among infants and newborns; it’s quite good nourishment at a reasonable price!
Pros
- Meets the FDA and USDA standards
- Prepared with organic partially hydrolyzed whey protein to reduce spit-ups and gas
- Calcium in the formula helps in bone development
- DHA helps with mental nourishment and vision
- A non-GMO and gluten-free formula for the safety of your baby
Cons
- Not suitable for infants with galactosemia
- Contains palm oil and land soy oil which some babies are sensitive to
Similac VS Enfamil Which Baby Formula Is Better?
It’s difficult to pick between Enfamil and Similac. Each of them has its own advantages and disadvantages.Â
For example, if you want less sugar in your baby’s milk, Enfamil has more options. Similac, on the other hand, offers a wide choice of lutein-rich products without the use of palm olein oil which some babies are sensitive to.
Again, each one has a different purpose of fulfilling. As for Enfamil, the Enfamil Infant works to give overall nourishment alongside helping in brain building. Again, the Enfamil Gentlease helps to relative gas, spit-ups, and crankiness in your child by reducing tummy trouble.
For Similac, the Similac Advance helps in brain and eye development and growth. And the Similac Pro Advance gives you everyday nutrition.
To sum up, deciding on the right formula totally depends on your baby’s digestive health. Whether you should go with Enfamil or Similac can be decided through the trial and error process, and then you can choose the formula which addresses most of the digestive issues of your baby!
What Can Be The Problems With Choosing A Baby Formula?
There is no infant formula that can be declared the best or perfect. Rather, you have to select the special one for your child after extensive research. Of course, your pediatrician can help in this case. Some of the problems you might face while choosing a baby formula and their solutions are discussed.
Choosing the right formula for babies with allergies:
If your baby has a food allergy or milk allergy, you can feed him/her a standard protein formula; you should look for an extensively hydrolyzed or amino-acid-based formula. Again, for babies who have lactose intolerance, you can select soy-based baby formulas
Homemade infant formula:
It is not recommended to go with homemade infant formula as it may not contain the right amount of certain nutrients, and may be too little, or too much, which can lead to some serious health conditions.
Low-weighed babies:
Soy-based formulas are not suggested for babies who were born with low weight.
Buying the formulas online:
Be cautious while purchasing formulas online through a third-party distributor, as they might not be genuine.
How to Choose The Best Formula For Your Baby
Before choosing a formula for your baby, you should keep in mind that there’s no perfect formula. However, there are a bunch of healthy options you can try. Mainly you need to check for the ingredients and their impact on your kid.
Observe the protein-based ingredients:
 A healthy baby can take standard protein formulae like the one present in Enfamil Infant, which includes nonfat milk or soy protein. However, some children show discomfort while digesting standard-sized proteins. In this case, they can go with partially hydrolyzed protein, just like the one is Gerber Goodstart SoothePro.
Check for the carbohydrate source:
A lactose-based formula is a good option for your baby. However, if he shows signs of indigestion, you can switch to reduced lactose or a formula with glucose sugar like corn syrup, glucose syrup, or so.
Other nutrients:
DHA, ARA, MFGM, and HMO are some of the additional nutrients that help in the mental development as well as growth and nourishment of your child. However, if one or two are missing out, there won’t be much problem.
There are some other factors you should consider. Like, avoid palm oil-based formulas if your child has constipation. And, go with whey-content-rich formula if he has the tendency to spit up often. Finally, consulting your pediatricians before choosing one is always appreciated!
Final Words
Finding a good baby formula for your baby can be as challenging as it is vital, especially with so many alternatives and varieties.
Before selecting the perfect formula for your dear baby, you should always consider your pediatrician’s advice. Ensure that you are buying the perfect protein and carbohydrate-content-based formula. Also, check for allergen information on the pack or jar. Finally, make sure to avoid broken cans or bottles and look for the expiration date.
As a matter of choosing a formula associated with your precious child’s comfort and proper nutrition, here’s hoping you will select the best Similac alternative that your baby is contended with!
FAQs
What about formulas made with goat’s milk?
Since goat milk has a high concentration of protein but lesser folate, fresh goat milk should not be given to the child during the first 12 months. After your child is a year old, some amount of this milk can be introduced into the diet after consulting with your doctor.
Is it possible for your baby to drink cow’s milk?
Once your baby crosses 12 months, you can feed him/her with cow’s milk. But if your baby has a milk allergy, you should consult your pediatrician.
What are the best Similac alternatives for your child?
Some of the best Similac alternatives for your child are Enfamil Gentlease, Enfamil Ensipre Gentlease, and Gerber Good Start SoothePro. They are lower in sugar content and higher in nutrients and promote healthy digestion.
What formula should a newborn who is allergic to cow’s milk be given?
For newborns who are allergic to cow’s milk, their formula should include partially hydrolyzed ingredients, which will provide your child with the desired nutrition. Or you can try switching to soy-based formulas too.
If my infant is allergic to cow’s milk, can I still drink it?
If your newborn is allergic to cow’s milk, and you are breastfeeding him/her, you have to make your diet free from dairy products like cheese, milk, yogurt, etc. Otherwise, the protein, upon passing on, can worsen the allergy.
How beneficial are the best Similac substitutes?
The beneficiary factor of a Simialc substitute will depend on how your baby’s digestive health reacts to it. While so many of the parents out there have found the right Similac substitutes filled with essential minerals and nutrients, some infants have been found allergic to specific ingredients in the formula.
What is the best formula for babies in the hospital?
Most hospitals use Similac formula for babies as it has the best ingredients.
Is Similac formula safe for infants?
Similac formulas have different varieties and options to choose from. They offer s your baby the complete nutrition required for development. This formula is absolutely safe for a healthy infant.
Read more:
How to Teach a Baby To Roll Over: 11 Tips from an Occupational Therapist
1 Response
[…] the perfect alternative to Similac can feel like a daunting task for new parents. With so many options available on the market, […]